November 19, 2026

How to Improve Strategic Decision Making

Picture of Adam Mendler

Adam Mendler

How to Improve Strategic Decision Making

A plan can be detailed and still leave its most important question unanswered. A forecast used in strategic decision making can show how much a new service would earn without showing that customers will pay for it. A staffing plan can show how many people you need without checking whether you can hire them before the work starts. The calculations may be right while the assumptions behind them remain untested. Before you approve the spending, ask which of those assumptions would change the decision if it turned out to be wrong.

In a 2025 study of entrepreneurs evaluating a business opportunity, researchers presented information designed to be balanced between accepting and rejecting the venture. Participants tended to interpret that information as supporting whichever option they already preferred. That interpretation increased their confidence in the choice. The pattern appeared whether they favored accepting or rejecting the opportunity. For strategic decision making, that gives you a reason to check what changed in the evidence when a team tells you it has become more certain.

Find the Assumption That Could Change the Decision

Start with the recommendation the team wants you to approve. Ask what has to happen for it to work. If a plan depends on customers switching suppliers, find out what the team knows about their willingness to switch. Interest in a meeting is different from agreeing to place an order at the price you need to charge. Before committing to the larger plan, ask the team what it could learn from asking for that order. In strategic decision making, check the assumption that could make you reject the plan, even if the other estimates hold up.

Make the forecasts used in strategic decision making easy to check. If a sales estimate comes from conversations with customers, record what they were shown, who was in the conversation, and what they agreed to. A buyer who likes an idea may still need somebody else to approve the budget. Ask whether that person has seen the offer and whether the money is available in the period you’re forecasting. Keep the notes where the person reviewing the estimate can find them without asking the salesperson to reconstruct every conversation.

Bring in the person who would have to make the promise work. If sales expects a new service to start within a month, ask the manager responsible for staffing it what has to happen first. Find out which people are available and which would have to come from work you’ve already committed to. Before the strategic decision making meeting, give that manager time to check what they can commit to. Compare that answer with the proposed launch date before promising it to customers.

Bring Better Evidence to Strategic Decision Making

When I interviewed Sonya Gafsi Oblisk of Whole Foods, she described how customers saw the store’s prices. Customers thought Whole Foods was more expensive than its actual prices justified, she said. The company had lowered prices on 25% of the items it sold, including more than 900 private-label products. It also worked on communicating the offers available. Oblisk reported record customer traffic during that period. When strategic decision making involves a price change, check whether customers are deciding on your actual price or an old impression of it.

Check whether the information in a proposal matches the customer and market the proposal is about. If your team recommends a price change, compare the offers available to the buyers you’re trying to reach. Keep delivery charges and any conditions on the offer with the price. For businesses researching several markets, proxy services such as DataImpulse can help teams access the offers shown in different locations. Record the location and date so somebody else can check the comparison. For strategic decision making about pricing, use the offer the customer could actually buy, with the conditions attached to it.

Ask what would show that the team’s explanation is wrong. If the team says customers are leaving because of price, talk to a few who paid more to buy from somebody else. Find out what they needed that your offer didn’t provide. If the team says a particular feature will win more business, ask the customers who requested it what they would do once it was available. Some may be ready to buy. Others may have additional requirements. You’ll have better information for strategic decision making if the research includes people whose choices challenge the explanation you started with.

Make It Possible to Disagree Before You Decide

Former Macy’s CEO Terry Lundgren told me that leaders can be the last to hear bad news. In his experience, employees sometimes hoped they could fix a problem before they had to report it. He also described inviting concerns when the company was preparing to put the Macy’s name on hundreds of department stores. He wanted people to tell him what could go wrong, even though he would ultimately make the decision. In a strategic decision making meeting, let the employee finish explaining the concern and ask what they’d need to check it.

Give people contributing to strategic decision making a chance to put their assessment in writing before you discuss your preferred answer. Ask what they recommend, what information they used, and which uncertainty concerns them most. Get the person who would do the work to explain what it would require. When the answers differ, keep both in the discussion long enough to find out why. Someone may know about a limit the rest of the team hasn’t seen. Ask the person with that information to show the team what they found before you settle the disagreement.

Consider how you respond when somebody’s information delays something you wanted to do. Ask what they found and what would resolve the concern. If the team needs a supplier to confirm a date, assign somebody to get the confirmation and agree on when you’ll decide. Thank the employee who surfaced the problem in front of the people who heard the original recommendation. They’ll see that raising it led to a better question and a next step. That’s a way to improve strategic decision making in the next meeting as well as the one you’re in.

Ask the Team to Explain How the Plan Could Fail

Before approving a major project, ask people to assume it has already failed and write down what happened. Give them time to do this independently before anyone shares an answer. Ask the people responsible for the work which of those failures they would notice first and what they could check now. Have them describe what they would see, such as an unfilled shift or a supplier who hasn’t confirmed a date. Bring those checks into the strategic decision making discussion before you approve spending that depends on the answers.

Start with the problems that could change whether you approve the project. If several people say the launch depends on a supplier whose date is still tentative, ask what you can confirm before approving the order. If customers would need months to move their records, check whether the revenue forecast allows that time. Decide which uncertainty needs resolving before you proceed and which you can afford to monitor. Assign each unresolved question to somebody who can check it before the next strategic decision making meeting.

One option in strategic decision making is to approve only enough work to answer the next question. A project may be worth trying even if you aren’t ready to fund every stage. Ask what the first stage could tell you and how much you’d have spent by the time you had an answer. Include commitments that would be difficult to reverse, such as a long lease or work promised to a customer. Then decide whether the early stage can answer the question before those commitments fall due. Make that answer a condition of approving the next stage.

Decide in Advance What Would Make You Reconsider

Decide how you’ll judge the result before you approve the spending. In a report published in 2025, Gartner said only 22% of organizations surveyed had defined, tracked, and communicated business impact metrics for the bulk of their data and analytics use cases. The survey involved 504 data and analytics leaders and was conducted in late 2024. Put the expected business result in the approval record, alongside the assumptions it depends on. If a project depends on customers moving from a trial to a paid plan, check that conversion before spending on another group of trials. Use those original estimates in your strategic decision making review so everybody can see what changed.

Agree on what would require another decision. Include the people who will see the change first and who can authorize a response. They need to know when to call you and what they can adjust themselves. In your strategic decision making review, take up findings like these before approving another commitment.

  • Customers try the service and won’t pay the planned price. Have the team show what those customers used and what they chose afterward. Review the offer before paying to bring in more people on the same terms.
  • The work takes longer than the plan allows. Ask the manager to compare the first completed jobs with the estimate. Revisit staffing and price before accepting enough work to make the delay hard to fix.


Look at how the finding affects the original reason for proceeding. A slower start may be manageable if the orders are profitable and the team has time to catch up. It needs a different response if each new order adds work you can’t staff at the price you quoted. Put both the cost and the customer commitments in front of the person who can change the plan. Set the review early enough that you can change the offer before you’ve promised it to more customers. Bring those commitments and the cost of changing them to the next strategic decision making meeting.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you make a strategic decision when you don’t have enough information?

Identify what you need to know to choose between the options available. Ask which unanswered question could actually change the choice, then work out how much time and money it would take to answer it. If the decision can be reversed at a manageable cost, a limited commitment may let you learn while doing the work. If it would lock the business into years of spending, more checking may be justified. In strategic decision making, how much uncertainty you can accept depends partly on what you’d be committing to before you learn more.

How do you get useful input from people who disagree with you?

Ask them to explain what they expect to happen and which information supports that view. Give them time to check facts with the people doing the work. In the meeting, take up the strongest concern before asking the rest of the team whether it agrees with your recommendation. If you proceed despite it, explain why you judge the risk acceptable and what would make you reconsider. That lets disagreement contribute to strategic decision making even when it doesn’t change the final choice.

Who should be in the decision meeting?

Include people who can explain the customer’s need, the cost, and what doing the work would require. They don’t all need to attend every meeting or have equal authority over the answer. Get their assessments before the decision, and bring them together when their assumptions conflict. Name the person who will choose once the relevant information is in. Strategic decision making becomes harder when employees have to reconcile commitments that their managers approved separately.

How can you tell whether a decision was good if the result was bad?

Go back to the information available when the decision was made. Check whether the team tested the assumptions it could reasonably test and considered the consequences of being wrong. Then look at what happened between approval and the result. A failure the team had no reasonable way to predict calls for a different response from a known risk nobody investigated. A record of the original reasoning makes that distinction possible and gives the next round of strategic decision making something useful to draw on.

When should you change course?

Reconsider when new information weakens a reason that mattered to the original decision. Ask the person closest to the work whether there’s a change that could address it and what that change would cost. Include what the business would have to give up to keep going, especially people’s time and work already promised elsewhere. Past spending is worth understanding, but the next decision concerns what you can still choose to spend. The record of your strategic decision making can show why it was reasonable to begin and why it’s now reasonable to stop.

Picture of Adam Mendler

Adam Mendler

Adam Mendler is a nationally recognized authority on leadership and is the creator and host of Thirty Minute Mentors, where he regularly elicits insights from America's top CEOs, founders, athletes, celebrities, and political and military leaders. Adam draws upon his unique background and lessons learned from time spent with America’s top leaders in delivering perspective-shifting insights as a leadership keynote speaker to businesses, universities, and non-profit organizations. A Los Angeles native and lifelong Angels fan, Adam teaches graduate-level courses on leadership at UCLA and is an advisor to numerous companies and leaders.

3x3 Leadership
Enjoy Adam’s monthly newsletter

share now

Email
LinkedIn
Facebook
Twitter

Learn how Adam can impact your organization

Cropped Blog Banner Picture scaled